Skip to main content

Yes, Your Time as a Parent Does Make a Difference [NYTimes.com]

02UP-Parenting-articleLarge

 

The latest salvo in the mommy wars is that all that time you spend parenting just doesn’t matter. But it’s a claim that, despite the enthusiastic and widespread coverage by news media outlets that include The Washington Post, Vox, The Guardian, The Independent, The Globe and Mail, NBC News, The Chicago Tribune and The New York Times’s Motherlode, does not hold water.

The claim that parenting time doesn’t matter is the bottom line of a single recent study by a team of sociologists who suggest that child outcomes are barely correlated with the time that parents spend with their children. It’s essentially a nonfinding, in that they failed to find correlations that could be reliably discerned from chance.

This nonfinding largely reflects the failure of the authors to accurately measure parental input. In particular, the study does not measure how much time parents typically spend with their children. Instead, it measures how much time each parent spends with children on only two particular days — one a weekday and the other a weekend day.

 

[For more of this story, written by Justin Wolfers, go to http://www.nytimes.com/2015/04...p;abt=0002&abg=1]

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 02UP-Parenting-articleLarge

Add Comment

Comments (1)

Newest · Oldest · Popular

Having only read this NY Times article, and not the full study, I feel somewhat reticent to criticize something I have not done my homework on.  The author makes a great point about how a study that looks at two days of time is not reflective of the life of a parent at all.  From my own perspective, I don't think that the amount of time a parent spends with his or her child is indicative of anything about their skill as a parent, it simply a measurement of time.  I have students who have spent 7 days a week with their parent throughout their childhood.  In some cases those students sat in the living room with their mom, while she smoked pot with an older sibling, drank alcohol, or sat in the kitchen with her mom while she cooked meth, or while the child watched her mom be abused by a  boyfriend... How is that measurement of time the same as the amount of time a parent spent reading to their child, or taking the child to the park, or baking cookies with the child.... 

 

Has anyone here read this study? Is it really as narrowly scoped as this writer indicates that it is? And if so, how does this stuff make the news? 

Post
Copyright © 2023, PACEsConnection. All rights reserved.
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×