Skip to main content

When a 10-year-old kills his Nazi father, who's to blame?

Natasha Vargas-Cooper's amazing story for Buzzfeed is a heartbreaking account of another case of our system failing a child miserably. Here's a taste:

At the beginning of the trial last October, Joseph's defense team argued that Joseph had been systematically abused — physically, emotionally, and possibly sexually — leaving him incapable of grasping concepts like right vs. wrong, empathy, and death. "This is an all-American story about child abuse," Joseph's juvenile public defender, Matt Hardy, said in his opening remarks. "What are we to expect from the brain of an abused 10-year-old?"

The prosecution insisted that Jeffrey did not abuse Joseph. Though Child Protective Services investigated the Hall family 23 times, no abuse could ever be substantiated; they argued that Joseph's horrific act of violence was "inevitable" because of Joseph's long-documented violent behavior. Joseph's own grandmother, a retired schoolteacher, said in a television interview that she knew her 10-year-old grandson was capable of murder; she just thought "it would happen later."

It's another classic case of how to grow a murderer, only even more tragic, because the murderer is 10 years old. 

Attachments

Images (1)
  • nazi

Add Comment

Comments (1)

Newest · Oldest · Popular

Thanks for posting this Jane. Society needs to take responsibility for growing/creating murderers instead of conveniently labeling many as "evil." It reminded me of a quote by a psychologist in a Christopher Dorner article:

"The poor and downtrodden, who have suffered unending, unspeakable abuse, … their internal lives are saturated in rage and a sense of utter helplessness," said Erika Sloane, a psychologist in Los Angeles. "I do
not see this as a reflection of individual failings or 'mental illness.'  I see the rage as a response to our increasingly corrupt, unjust, unresponsive culture."

From: Christopher Dorner Not A Sociopath, Experts Say, HuffPo 2/14/13 http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/02/14/christopher-dorner-sociopath-experts_n_2679125.html?ncid=edlinkusaolp00000003

Post
Copyright © 2023, PACEsConnection. All rights reserved.
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×