Skip to main content

Punch After Punch, Rape After Rape, a Murderer Was Made [nytimes.com]

 

Laura's note (added 12/24/20): This article contains graphic descriptions of sexual assault and abuse.

This article contains descriptions of sexual assault.

On Jan. 12, Lisa Montgomery is set to become the first woman executed on federal death row in nearly 70 years. The last executions, both in 1953, were of Bonnie Heady, killed in a gas chamber in Missouri, and Ethel Rosenberg. Ms. Montgomery would be only the fifth woman put to death in a federal civilian execution, according to the Death Penalty Information Center.

On Dec. 16, 2004, Ms. Montgomery drove to Skidmore, Mo., where she strangled a pregnant woman named Bobbie Jo Stinnett, then sliced open her belly and took the baby to the home she shared with her husband, Kevin, in Kansas. The baby survived.

These basic facts, however, are nearly all that is not under dispute in the case. Her post-conviction lawyers, Kelley Henry, Amy Harwell and Lisa Nouri, have sent a petition to the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights claiming that Ms. Montgomery’s trial “fell far short of minimum standards of fairness” and thus violated international law, and that the United States government itself bears some culpability for her crime given its abject failure, throughout her life, to protect her from severe child abuse and sexual violence.

On Dec. 1, the commission ruled that the execution would result in “irreparable harm” and requested a delay until it has had the chance to reach a decision on Ms. Montgomery’s petition. The commission’s rulings are not legally binding, but past ones have resulted in stayed executions in Ohio and Texas.

In addition to this petition, more than one thousand supporters have put forth their own letters and petitions, including prosecutors, anti-trafficking and domestic violence organizations, and mental health practitioners.
[To read the rest of this opinion piece by Rachel Louise Snyder, click here.]
[Illustration: Aidan Koch]

Add Comment

Comments (5)

Newest · Oldest · Popular

Agreed. This is of course an extreme case (although not isolated). As horrific as the story is, I'm hopeful to see it detailed in a mainstream newspaper with a large readership -- the more such stories are shared with people not working in an ACEs-enlightened field (people outside of "the choir"), the more may come to understand the connection between, this case, crime and a history of abuse and therefore realize the need for systemic change. That said, I wonder if sharing such an extreme example without acknowledging that less-extreme experiences also contribute to crime and other social and health problems is a disservice -- not that that was the point of this editorial. All in due time, I suppose.

Yes, agreed! I cringed when I read this part: "On an Adverse Childhood Experiences test, Ms. Montgomery scored nine out of 10 — a number that coincides with the most extreme forms of torture."

I know plenty of folks with a 9 ACEs score who would not have considered their childhood "torture". I fear that calling a high ACEs score "torture" leads to "otherizing" instead of helping people see that child trauma impacts us all.

Hi Laura! Nothing you did wrong here...I just was shocked at this level of child torture. It did take me a few days to process it...that's how shocking it is. It makes me glad we work in this field of child abuse prevention because there is so much work to be done!

Agreed. This is of course an extreme case (although not isolated). As horrific as the story is, I'm hopeful to see it detailed in a mainstream newspaper with a large readership -- the more such stories are shared with people not working in an ACEs-enlightened field (people outside of "the choir"), the more may come to understand the connection between, this case, crime and a history of abuse and therefore realize the need for systemic change. That said, I wonder if sharing such an extreme example without acknowledging that less-extreme experiences also contribute to crime and other social and health problems is a disservice -- not that that was the point of this editorial. All in due time, I suppose.

Alison, perhaps I should have added a warning beyond the one the article provided. The type and degree of abuse is beyond what one typically reads in a newspaper, or anywhere. I apologize and hope you are OK.

Hi Laura! Nothing you did wrong here...I just was shocked at this level of child torture. It did take me a few days to process it...that's how shocking it is. It makes me glad we work in this field of child abuse prevention because there is so much work to be done!

I'm glad you posted this here but I extremely regret reading this whole piece! This is one of the most gut-wrenching and heartbreaking stories of extreme child abuse I've ever read. :'(

Alison, perhaps I should have added a warning beyond the one the article provided. The type and degree of abuse is beyond what one typically reads in a newspaper, or anywhere. I apologize and hope you are OK.

Post
Copyright © 2023, PACEsConnection. All rights reserved.
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×