Skip to main content

Meant To Keep Youths Out Of Detention, Probation Often Leads Them There [NPR.org]

img_8614_wide-776274ce461bbdd92c16ea22f651ac7b2444aa59-s1600-c85

 

 

Juvenile justice reformers have tried for years to figure out what works to help rehabilitate youth in trouble, and a recent shift away from locking kids up has been at the forefront of reform efforts. One of the most common alternatives to incarceration is to order kids directly into probation, instead of juvenile hall.

But the goals of these alternative approaches don't always match the reality ā€” and disproportionately impact youth of color.

The juvenile hall in San Leandro, Calif., has 360 beds ā€” most of which were full when the detention center opened eight years ago. Today, the facility is half-empty.

Nationwide in the past 16 years, juvenile incarceration dropped by half. Part of the reason? Judges across the country, including in Alameda County, are ordering young offenders into the probation system as an alternative to locking kids up.

That's what happened to one 18-year-old, whom Youth Radio is not naming in order to protect his privacy and his juvenile records, which are protected by the law. He stole two pairs of sneakers, worth $85 total, when he was 15. This was his second arrest for what the court found to be a minor offense.

 

[For more of this story, written by Soraya Shockley, go to http://www.npr.org/2015/07/29/...n-juvenile-detention]

Attachments

Images (1)
  • img_8614_wide-776274ce461bbdd92c16ea22f651ac7b2444aa59-s1600-c85

Add Comment

Comments (2)

Newest · Oldest · Popular

I agree.   

 

We MUST address the trauma.   Many communities have no resources.  We have no resources in NE Michigan.  The money that is spent on prisons and "revenge" would be much better spent PREVENTING and then MITIGATING trauma --- often trauma that has been generations in the making.  

 

Nothing else will do.  If we don't stop this --- we have less attractive communities and kids who suffered just continue to be made to suffer and feel shame.  

 

Adults need lots of education about this.   

 

 

 

 

Last edited by Former Member

Nothing will work to change the brains of young people if we don't address the trauma. Destructive, bad behaviors can be the direct result of unresolved trauma. It is imperative we screen all youth entering the juvenile justice system for their Adverse Childhood Experiences and probation must include more than reporting to a probation officer and community service. Probation must include interventions specific to that youth and his/her family. We will get the same results if we continue to do the same thing. We have to change more than the cage youth are held.

 

~ Dr. Cathy Anthofer-Fialon

Post
Copyright Ā© 2023, PACEsConnection. All rights reserved.
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×