Skip to main content

“PACEs

Aiming for Discipline Instead of Punishment (edutopia.org)

 

There are many perspectives on the topic of discipline in our classrooms and schools, and I’d like to explore the idea of using brain-aligned discipline with students who have adverse childhood experiences (ACEs). 

Discipline, unlike punishment, is proactive and begins before there are problems. It means seeing conflict as an opportunity to problem solve. Discipline provides guidance, focuses on prevention, enhances communication, models respect, and embraces natural consequences. It teaches fairness, responsibility, life skills, and problem solving. 

The neurobiological changes caused by chronic negative experiences and a history of adversity can trigger a fear response in the brain. As Pam Leo says, “A hurtful child is a hurt-filled child. Trying to change her behavior with punishment is like trying to pull off only the top part of the weed. If we don’t get to the root, the hurtful behavior pops up elsewhere.” In children the fear response often looks aggressive, defiant, and oppositional.

Young people with ACEs have brains that are in a constant state of alarm. In this alarm state, consequences don’t register properly. Discipline can only be done when both the educator and the student are calm and self-regulated. If they aren’t, behavioral difficulties will escalate. 

PREVENTIVE BRAIN-ALIGNED STRATEGIES

Could your school create a area for both teachers and students to go to when they need to reset their emotional state? This area could be stocked with paper, markers, crayons, water, soft music and lighting, a jump rope, a stationary bike, lavender scented cotton balls, jars for affirmations or worries, or a rocking chair. Students will need to be taught ahead of time how to use this area, which they should need for just two to five minutes in order to feel refocused and ready to return to class.

To read more of Lori Desautel's article, please click here.

Add Comment

Comments (3)

Newest · Oldest · Popular

Thank you, Jim. Concurring, the culture shift of creating safe spaces where students (and school staff) can calm their amygdala and access their pre-frontal cortex isn't about not holding children/youth/adults accountable. There's not an aspect of this paradigm shift that is not about holding individuals accountable.

Rather, how can systems create an environment where every adult on campus (front office staff, lunch court, cafeteria, etc.) understands how our brains work and look at behavior as a cry for help. Supporting the cry for help with calming techniques and peaceful environments will support that child/youth's regulating their emotions, calming themselves, and refocusing to their classroom environment.

Profoundly uplifted with so many early adopters on the front line of systems change, like yourself, the shift of trauma-informed, resilience-building schools across our nation is gaining traction. Such a transformative culture shift filled with hope and healing.

Thanks for posting this Dana! One of the first challenges I have as a trauma-informed school design-thinker/coach when assisting schools in changing to this new trauma-informed culture is in their understanding of Discipline v. Punishment. Or more specifically; the concept of consequences.

Post
Copyright © 2023, PACEsConnection. All rights reserved.
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×