Skip to main content

Reply to "Review article or meta-analysis of ways to address childhood trauma"

Cambria Walsh posted:

Hi Russell,

On Seeking Safety,

I wouldn’t call Cochrane a “clear endorsement” – the effects didn’t last post intervention.  This is why it is rated as it was by the CEBC.  They look at sustainment of effects and for trauma treatment it didn't meet the necessary length of sustainment to warrant a higher rating.

Acceptance and Commitment Therapy is on the CEBC, but under treatment for depression since that is it's primary target: http://www.cebc4cw.org/program...ent-therapy/detailed

Progressive counting is due for review this fall – research last reviewed September 2015.  If the program representative  or other users don't submit research as it is published, then it is caught when the CEBC does an independent review every two years.

If there are others with evidence that you would like them to add, they are always happy for suggestions!  You can submit via the contact us form on the website. http://www.surveygizmo.com/s3/...CEBC-Contact-Us-copy 

 On-line treatments were only just recently added on the CEBC.  At your suggestion, Computerized Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (cCBT) is now being added to the potential programs list.  RAND Europe did a recent review, and there are a lot of different providers.  If you have any particular versions in mind, they would welcome some suggestions.

I used to manage the CEBC so I do have some insider info and know that they are welcoming of suggestions and feedback! 

Thanks for your suggestions!

 

Cambria

 

Does it look at programs for those with Emotion Dysregulation?  -- of course, a long established cornerstone of DBT, and with two separate programs developed "in recent times" (at least since 2010), and of course there's long been an argument for ERT as the first phase of  a two-phase program for trauma (which European researchers have found (Dorrepaal's group, recently, isn't required in their programs.

As for ACT "depression (since that) is its primary target".... I suggest they look into Robyn Walser and what she does at the VA. She's been publishing on ACT for trauma for over 20 years. The ACT folk would probably be upset to hear that any particular disorder is their primary target -- transdiagnostic is one of their main tenets, they would probably say.

Last edited by Jane Stevens
Copyright © 2023, PACEsConnection. All rights reserved.
×
×
×
×